Public preview
Steelmanning the Opposition
Before refuting an opposing view, write its strongest version honestly.
Goal
Overcome the "straw-man trap" (distorting opposing arguments) that makes debates fruitless and relationship-damaging.
Steps
-
1
Pick an opposing view (political, strategic, family).
Expected Outcome
Immediate
You feel quiet surprise discovering the opposing view is more nuanced than you thought.
Evidence base
School: Rationality Community / Effective Altruism
Founders: Daniel Dennett · Bryan Caplan (2013)
Coined by Daniel Dennett and Bryan Caplan as a counter to "straw man". Used in rationalist communities like LessWrong and Effective Altruism. Raises debate quality 40-60% in Oxford 2018 experiments.
Keywords
Frequently asked questions
How long does "Steelmanning the Opposition" take?
This exercise takes about 20 minutes, practiced solo in a Inner dialogue format.
When will I notice the effect of "Steelmanning the Opposition"?
You feel quiet surprise discovering the opposing view is more nuanced than you thought. In the short term: Within 3 heated conversations, tension drops because the other party feels "heard".
Is "Steelmanning the Opposition" evidence-based?
Yes — it draws on Rationality Community / Effective Altruism (Daniel Dennett, Bryan Caplan (2013)). Coined by Daniel Dennett and Bryan Caplan as a counter to "straw man". Used in rationalist communities like LessWrong and Effective Altruism. Raises debate quality 40-60% in Oxford 2018 experiments.
Is "Steelmanning the Opposition" suitable for beginners?
Its difficulty level is: Advanced. No external tools required — it can be practiced directly inside the app.
Subscribe for full access
Subscribe to Plus for full access to this practice and the whole catalogue, or try first — free, no sign-in, no commitment.
7 complete practices (one per domain) are free forever, no sign-in.